On Tuesday, the first criminal charge was filed in relation to the the 2010 Deepwater Horizon BP oil spill. Kurt Mix, a BP drilling engineer, is charged with felony obstruction of justice, in addition to facing about $500,000 in fines.
Allegedly, Mix deleted hundreds of text messages to his supervisor that described the oil that was leaking from the well. The messages in question stated that the operation to plug the well, “Top Kill,” was failing. However, when Mix became aware that his phone texts and calls might be summoned by BP’s attorneys, he reportedly deleted them.
During the spill, BP was frequently giving the government incorrect information regarding the the amount of discharge. BP claimed that there were 1,000 to 5,000 barrels of oil flowing per day; however, the government estimate taken from the wellhead concluded there was more than 10 times that amount. Besides giving false estimates, BP also told government representatives prior to the spill that they were prepared to handle an oil spill at the Deepwater Horizon location. Obviously, they were mistaken.
Officials from BP assured the public as well as the U.S. government that the best estimate for oil spilled per day was around 5,000 barrels per day, but in August 2011 one of the consultants working at BP’s U.S. headquarters indicated that they were aware the flow rate was much larger than that. The consultant, who wished to remain anonymous, stated “Our calculations suggested to us that it was much higher than the number that was being talked about…The top kill operation had a very, very low likelihood of working based on the volumes we were seeing from the well.” The public was told that “Top Kill” had a 60–70% chance of working.
The charges against Mix are only the first of many to come, in addition to the $7.8 billion settlement BP recently finalized with the hundreds of thousands of businesses and families affected by the disaster.